WordPress vs Shopify SEO: which is better for optimization?

WordPress and Shopify both claim to be good for SEO, but which one is truly better for you? While WordPress is designed for content-heavy websites, Shopify is made for beginner merchants who want to sell products and achieve higher rankings.

In this guide, we’ll break down how both Shopify and WordPress compare in terms of key SEO areas and which is best for your business.

Simplify SEO and automate tasks on Shopify with TinyIMG

Automatic JSON-LD setup

Speed boosting features

Try TinyIMG

WordPress vs Shopify SEO overview

WordPress and Shopify are both great platforms for SEO, but they focus on different areas. Shopify is meant for selling and is made easy to use for beginner merchants, while WordPress offers more customization options but a bigger learning curve.

Let’s review the main SEO areas in a summarized table:

What’s important for SEO in a hosting platform?

Website builders with managed hosting should ensure that your site has a chance to rank in search engines, taking care of technical SEO and back-end optimizations. Here’s what to consider:

• URL management. An SEO-friendly platform should offer a clear and descriptive URL structure to help search engines understand your website navigation and structure.
• Themes. Even themes can affect SEO, since poor coding can hurt Core Web Vitals results. Choose a platform that offers lightweight and time-tested themes and check reviews before purchasing.
• Speed optimization. Page load time is a ranking factor, and platforms should have an optimized infrastructure to make it as fast as possible. Look for platforms with caching and CDN, but also optimize performance, like images and scripts, on your end to achieve the best results.
• Security. Google has been using HTTPS as a ranking signal since 2014, so prioritize platforms that offer free SSL certificates and good uptime.
• On-page SEO features. Make sure a platform provides easy SEO metadata editing and alt text optimization. It should also make it simple to create URL handles and manage redirects.

WordPress vs Shopify SEO compared

Before analyzing the SEO of WordPress and Shopify, keep in mind that this guide covers WordPress.com instead of WordPress.org.

WordPress.org is a self-hosted platform, meaning you’re responsible for all technical setup, performance, and hosting. It serves different needs and levels of technical expertise. Shopify and WordPress.com are fully managed solutions, so we compared how they stack up to each other.

eCommerce SEO

Shopify takes care of some eCommerce SEO parts for you, like providing themes that are optimized for mobile devices and using a CDN. It also allows you to edit SEO meta titles and meta descriptions, which help search engines understand what your page is about and motivate users to click.

For images, you can also easily edit alt texts, which allow Google and other search engines to understand the context of your image.

On WordPress, SEO metadata and alt text editing, responsiveness, and other optimization features are also available. 

However, WordPress and Shopify don’t include structured data automatically to enable enhanced search listings.

It means that your product pages won’t be optimized for rich results by default. Instead, you’ll have to use Shopify apps like TinyIMG or WordPress plugins like Yoast SEO.

SEO blogging

WordPress is primarily built as a content management system (CMS) rather than an eCommerce tool. You can use it to create a clear blog structure and pillar pages, so it’s excellent for stores that want to prioritize SEO-friendly content creation.

It has better categorization and reading options than Shopify. For example, you can set what posts to display on your homepage, manage indexing, select how many posts per page to show, and more. The CMS also feels more feature-rich, letting you archive posts or add quote blocks.

WordPress makes it easy to implement topic clusters because of its flexible URL structures and content hierarchy.

As for Shopify, the categorization isn’t as flexible. It uses blogs as top-level organization and tags for secondary organization. When you open the blog post, you can assign it to a blog of your choice or insert tags.

Still, you can create powerful blog posts even with Shopify. Its blog builder lets you edit SEO metadata, add excerpts, tables, lists, indents, media, and perform all other customizations.

URL customization

Having a clean URL structure helps search engines understand your page content and site structure. It also makes navigation easier for your site’s visitors.

Shopify uses a specific URL structure that’s difficult to customize. For example, while an SEO-friendly URL structure would look like this:

https://example.com/skincare/moisturizers

But if you open any Shopify merchant’s site, it will look similar to this:

https://example.com/collections/skincare/products/moisturizers

The URL structure can’t be changed, so you’re stuck with the /products/ and /collections/ parts in the URL. You can only edit the URL handle.

Meanwhile, WordPress gives you control over your permalinks, so you can create an SEO-friendly and clean URL structure. For example, you can use the post name structure:

https://example.com/tutorial/how-to-make-bread/

Alternatively, you can use numeric, month and name, day and name, or a custom permalink structure.

Technical SEO control

Technical SEO focuses on how search engines crawl and index your site. It can directly impact whether your pages appear in search engine results pages (SERPs) at all.

Shopify handles some parts of technical SEO automatically, like generating canonical tags or managing duplicate URLs. It also creates and updates the robots.txt file automatically. All of this makes Shopify excellent for beginner users who don’t want to get into technicalities.

Still, Shopify limits control over technical SEO. For example, users can only customize the robots.txt file through Liquid files, and managing page indexing is only possible through third-party apps.

On WordPress, you get more customization options, including the ability to set noindex tags. If you want advanced management of canonical URLs or robots.txt file editing, you’ll need to use a plugin.

Duplicate content

Duplicate content refers to the technical SEO issue where two or more web pages include similar or even identical content, like similar products or filtered pages. It may confuse search engines on which version to rank, which can negatively affect visibility and rankings.

Shopify manages common duplicate content issues automatically through canonical tags. For example, if a product is put into multiple collections, Shopify will still point to the main version of the page.

In some cases, default canonical tags may not point to the preferred version, so you’d need to add them manually. Canonical tags can be added before the </head> tag in your theme layout file:

<link rel="canonical" href="{{ canonical_url }}">

WordPress also applies canonical tags for duplicate content by default, and it’s also more flexible. You can install SEO plugins that offer canonical tag management, but make sure you understand what you need to do to prevent human error.

Themes

Many first-time website owners choose a theme based on its visual design, but it’s just as important to look at how well it’s optimized for Core Web Vitals and SEO.

The Shopify Theme Store is filled with 1,100+ themes that have all gone through the platform’s strict requirements for responsiveness, security, and performance. Over 20 themes are completely free to use, while others you can customize for free and only pay a one-time fee when or if you publish them.

Shopify themes offer a clean and structured code to prevent significant bugs or technical SEO issues. While there’s limited control over deep customization, it’s more focused on non-technical users. You can still edit the basics, like adding sections, changing fonts, or adding visuals, and create a fully functional site.

WordPress doesn’t state the number of themes they offer, but they claim it’s in the thousands. Many of their themes are highly customizable and mobile-friendly, and you can also access theme codes for any technical SEO improvements.

WordPress themes are free, but specific themes are available for specific plan users. For example, some options are only available with the Personal or Premium plans.

Speed and performance

Speed has been a ranking factor on Google for years, especially through Core Web Vitals. For a managed hosting platform, most of the speed optimizations should be done for you.

Shopify handles speed optimization on the platform level, taking care of server maintenance and back-end optimizations. Here are the main areas it takes care of:

• Global servers are optimized for performance and have no bandwidth limits.
• It uses a Content Delivery Network (CDN) backed by Cloudflare, meaning it loads cached copies of your website from the server that’s closest to your site’s visitors.
• For returning visitors, Shopify uses browser caching for one year to ensure faster page load times.
• To make sure images don’t overload your store, it serves the WebP format automatically, which is around 25-34% smaller in file size compared to PNG and JPG at a similar quality.

With managed hosting, WordPress.com takes care of server maintenance and includes a CDN, just like Shopify.

The self-hosted WordPress.org platform leaves hosting, server optimization, CDN setup, caching, and all other areas to you. It’s only suitable for users who are tech-savvy.

That said, with both Shopify and WordPress.com, back-end optimizations aren’t enough. We’ve noticed how Shopify merchant sites slow down after large site customizations.

So, take extra speed optimization steps, like running your page through PageSpeed Insights, applying image compression, and setting up lazy loading, to maintain fast page load times.

SSL certificates

Google and other search engines prioritize HTTPS as a light ranking factor, so using SSLs is essential for SEO and improving site visibility.

SSL certificates are digital documents that enable a secure and encrypted connection between a web server and the browser to protect sensitive data, including passwords, from being stolen. 

A website has an SSL certificate if the URL uses the “HTTPS” protocol instead of “HTTP” and includes a padlock icon.

WordPress.com automatically adds free SSL certificates for all of your domains and subdomains. Shopify also sets up SSL certificates for you, so you don’t need to take care of this security area.

Third-party apps and plugins

Third-party apps allow stores to expand platform functionality and get tools for more in-depth SEO optimization. For example, on Shopify, you can get comprehensive apps that offer easy JSON-LD setup, LLMs.txt generation to help AI models understand your content, and speed optimization.

WordPress offers SEO plugins as well, and they offer more in-depth customization. For example, you can use a plugin like Yoast SEO to automatically generate sitemaps and breadcrumbs, manage redirects, and more.

Keep in mind that having too many apps can slow down your website, which can affect bounce rates and rankings. Most of our clients with fast websites keep just 2-5 apps in total.

If you’re planning to sell, we’d recommend Shopify because it comes with built-in eCommerce features, making it possible to sell without any apps. With WordPress, you’d need to install the WooCommerce add-on to be able to sell.

Which one to choose: WordPress or Shopify

WordPress offers more flexibility in terms of SEO, but Shopify excels for non-technical users who want to sell products online. WordPress is more suited for website owners who prioritize creating SEO-friendly content, while selling requires the WooCommerce plugin.

At the end of the day, SEO isn’t just about which platform you choose. All of our clients who have achieved the highest rankings with their Shopify websites wouldn’t have gotten there without on-page SEO optimizations and backlink strategies.

×

About the author

Kristina Jaruseviciute

Kristina is a Content Lead at TinyIMG responsible for informing and educating readers on all things Shopify-related. She covers a broad range of topics around SEO, AI visibility, website performance, and conversion rates to help merchants stand out in a competitive landscape.